Find Us facebook twitter youtube linkedin linkedin
  • Shrimp Fever > 2013 > August > 26 > OK, so repeat the process using a spinning jar

    OK, so repeat the process using a spinning jar

    August 26th, 2013  |  Published in Uncategorized

    Discovery Institute Gives Us Their Best Argument

    Things aren going very well for the neo theocrats at the Discovery Institute creationist public canada goose outlet in canada relations and lobbying operation, the Center for Science and Culture (a/k/a the Discoveroids, a/k/a the cdesign proponentsists).

    canada goose black friday sale At their blog today is this new post by Granville Sewell: Are You Looking for the Simplest and Clearest Argument for canada goose discount uk Intelligent Design? canada goose outlet woodbury We written about Sewell before (see Discovery Institute Touts Another Genius). canada goose black friday sale

    Canada Goose sale We won spend any time rebutting what Sewell says today, because it not worth the effort. But it definitely worth noting that the canada goose outlet london uk Discoveroids canada goose stockists uk think this is their best argument. Sewell starts out quoting something he wrote earlier. The bold font was added by us: Canada Goose sale

    canada goose uk black friday [I prefer to dwell further on] the much simpler and clearer https://www.canadagooseoutlete.com/ second point of my article, which is that the increase canada goose outlet in new york in order observed on Earth (and here alone, as far as we know) violates the laws canada goose outlet store quebec of probability and the second law of thermodynamics in a spectacular fashion. canada goose uk black friday

    canada goose factory sale It our old friend so often cited by creationists canada goose outlet winnipeg the second law of thermodynamics. Sewell continues quoting canada goose outlet new york himself: canada goose factory sale

    cheap Canada Goose Evolutionists have always dismissed this argument by saying that the second law of thermodynamics only dictates that order cannot increase in an isolated (closed) system, and the Earth is not a closed system in particular, it receives energy from the Sun. The second law allows order to increase locally, provided the local increase is offset by an canada goose outlet belgium equal or greater decrease canada goose outlet washington dc in the rest of the universe. cheap Canada Goose

    Yes, that right. Then Sewell (still quoting himself) carries things to a bit of an extreme:

    canadian goose jacket This always seems to be the end of the argument: order can increase (entropy can decrease) in an open system, therefore, ANYTHING can happen in an open system, even the rearrangement of atoms into computers, without violating the second law. canadian goose jacket

    buy canada goose jacket We never heard anyone (except a creationist) make such a claim, but that Sewell defense of his Second Law argument. Now let give you one more excerpt canada goose kensington parka uk from the end. Here, Sewell isn quoting himself; he writing canada goose outlet store calgary in the present: buy canada goose jacket

    canada goose uk shop I still consider this argument to be the simplest and clearest argument for intelligent design that it is possible to make, and I consider this video [at the Discoveroid post] to be the simplest and clearest presentation of this argument I have ever made. Unfortunately, it seems to be too simple for many scientists, canada goose outlet buffalo and generally only appreciated by non scientists mathematicians. canada goose uk shop

    Canada Goose Jackets So canada goose outlet edmonton there you canada goose outlet usa have it. You seen the very best argument for intelligent design. If you not persuaded now, there no hope for you. The Sensuous Curmudgeon. Canada Goose Jackets

    canada goose uk outlet Actually thermodynamics is the worst enemy of ID. The thing is, they are proposing that intelligence canada goose outlet black friday sale allows for the breaking of the second law canada goose outlet uk sale of thermodynamics. But that computer you were talking canada goose outlet vip about. Well, it would not be possible to build canada goose outlet miami it without the input of energy. Intelligence operates with energy, not a single step in building the computer can be done without energy, meaning that intelligence cannot be an explanation for breaking thermodynamics laws. Their philosophical foundations are nonexistent. They canada goose outlet store uk pretend to be inspired by human intelligence to propose ID. Yet, if they followed their own argument they would have to admit that our intelligence, and everything we do with that intelligence, does not break any laws either, thus, if the second canada goose outlet sale law were a problem canada goose uk site for evolution, it would be a problem for ID as well. canada goose uk outlet

    Canada Goose Outlet I no expert in grammar, but I assume that, by increase in order observed on Earth he means that the order is observed, not the increase. But whatever he means, temorary, localized increases of order are regularly observed. Which mean that, in DI so are the violations of their precious (caricature of) 2LoT. Canada Goose Outlet

    Canada Goose Parka As you know, to avoid the questions that even some of the most clueless audiences react with, they quickly backpedal from canada goose outlet legit the argument canada goose parka uk to the one. And that usually fools the rest, and forces the canada goose outlet 2015 critics into rebuttals that require too much time or interest for most peple to follow. Net result, the DI sound bites trickle down to 3/4 of the public. Canada Goose Parka

    canada goose coats No. The best argument the DI has is canada goose outlet near me the Darwin to Hitler nonsense. That they have had to canada goose outlet store toronto play that card means that they are saying lying, we know canada goose outlet in montreal it, and you can do a thing about it. comment > canada goose coats

    Canada Goose online (Slightly modified because the above is a bit hard to understand.) Canada Goose online

    canada goose clearance sale Actually thermodynamics is the worst enemy of ID. The thing is, canada goose outlet they are [implicitly but quietly] proposing that intelligence allows for the breaking of the second law of thermodynamics. But that canada goose outlet price computer. Well. It would not be possible to build it without the input of energy. Intelligence operates with energy, not a single step in building the computer can be done without energy, meaning that intelligence cannot be an explanation for breaking thermodynamics laws. Their philosophical foundations are nonexistent. They pretend to be inspired by human intelligence to propose ID. Yet, if they followed their own argument they would have to admit that our intelligence, and everything we do with that intelligence, does not break any laws either. Thus, intelligence cannot be an explanation for breaking any laws. Conversely, if the second law were a problem for evolution, it would be a problem for ID as well. canada goose clearance sale

    uk canada goose Then Sewell (still quoting himself) caries things to a bit of an canada goose outlet store new york extreme: uk canada goose

    Canada Goose Online No, our Curmie knows that the most Brilliant Creationists, the most politically savvy, the cream de la cream are all DENTISTS! Canada Goose Online

    canada goose clearance Obviously, Granville, in his dementia, thinks he risen from a lowly professor of mathematics at a tumbleweed strewn west Texas university (cue coyote howl) to the height of Creationist Creamdom a Dentist. The carie, of course, canada goose outlet online store review refers to the cavity between Gran ears where his brain used to be. canada goose clearance

    canada goose Yeah, Grannery, you are Sooooooo misunderstood because of your brilliance, I mean, dood, we just can see for all the Light! Now, take your little blue pills like a good boy and later tonight we look under your bed canada goose outlet nyc together to make sure the leprechauns are gone. canada goose

    canada goose store no offense intended to UTEP which, other that for a few idiots like canada goose jacket outlet uk Grannie, is a fine university. canada goose store

    Canada Goose Coats On Sale Perhaps UTEP in his case ought to be considered an epithet rather than an canada goose premium outlet acronym. My wife cousin, who lived in El Paso, was fond of commenting that in German, a is canada goose outlet florida an idiot. Canada Goose Coats On Sale

    cheap canada goose uk Sewell knows that his argument is bs. He has been corrected by many commenters, including prominent scientists. cheap canada goose uk

    The open/closed system is a red herring, an irrelevant distraction.

    canada goose coats on sale Using or as a substitute for negative entropy change is where he introduces the switch. But even where ordering canada goose parka outlet is so used, simple doable experiments can be shown to generate considerable order in isolated systems. A couple of examples: Start with a jar full of a sand/water mix. Shake it up to create a slurry. Set the jar down and the system will spontaneously increase in order, as the sand settles. But, you might say, this system isn really isolated; the earth s gravitational canada goose outlet niagara falls field is influencing the sand behavior. OK, so repeat the process using a spinning jar. Settling will occur even without any gravity. Even better, start with a sealed bottle containing water and suitable nutrients, say dissolved sugar. Introduce one yeast bacterium cell, and wait. Pretty soon you will have zillions of cells. an obvious increase in order, with no outside influence required. Sewell rest of the universe is beside the point here, since that bottle can be made completetly independent of surroundings, and still the order will increase substantially. So we can show that canada goose outlet vancouver in isolated systems, order can increase. This obviously does not violate any thermodynamic law, since it is readily observed. canada goose coats on sale

    buy canada goose jacket cheap Sewell states in his article: we have a simple, clear proof of a theorem, and a long, canada goose outlet location complicated, counter argument, full of hotly debated and unverifiable points, we accept the simple proof, even before we find the errors in the complicated argument. is trying to set up the case that his 2nd law of thermodynamics argument is the simple proof of intelligent design. Given the choice between a simple proof, and a long complicated counter argument, mathematicians will always choose the simple proof. Sewell clearly prefers not to try and understand a long complicate argument. buy canada goose jacket cheap

    uk canada goose outlet However, he makes a good point. For any given observation of nature, which is the most complicated explanation, a natural process or intelligent design uk canada goose outlet.

    Leave a Response

    © 2018 Shrimp Fever Ltd.  All Rights are Reserved